The Role Of Rationalist And Progressive Muslim Scholars In Nurturing Islamic Natural Law Theories

By Adis Duderija, New Age Islam 14 November 2024 In the Islamic intellectual history, few contributions have been as profound and far-reaching as those of rationalist scholars who shaped the development of Islamic natural law theories. They stand out not only for their philosophical insights but also for their commitment to reason as a guiding principle in understanding morality and justice. This essay seeks to briefly outline the contributions of these scholars and their impact on Islamic jurisprudence, while also examining the subsequent decline of rationalist thought in the Islamic world after the thirteenth century and how contemporary progressive Muslimscholars are reviving Islamic natural law theories. The Rationalist Tradition in Islamic Thought The rationalist tradition in Islamic philosophy emerged in a context where diverse intellectual currents were converging. Philosophers such as Abū Bakr al-Rāzī and Ibn al-Hasan al-Tūsī engaged deeply with the works of Greek philosophers, particularly Aristotle and Plato, while simultaneously addressing the unique challenges posed by Islamic theology. This synthesis of Hellenistic philosophy and Islamic thought laid the groundwork for a rich discourse on natural rights and the moral foundations of law. Among the notable figures is Ibn Bāja (d. 533/1139), who emphasized the importance of reason as a means to understand the divine order. His writings reflect a belief that human beings, endowed with reason, can discern natural laws that govern both the cosmos and human conduct. Similarly, Ibn Rushd(d. 595/1198), known in the West as Averroes, championed the harmony between religion and philosophy. His commentaries on Aristotle were pivotal in promoting rational inquiry as a legitimate path to understanding religious truths. Another significant thinker, Ibn Tufayl(d. 581/1185), explored the implications of natural law through his philosophical novel Hayy ibn Yaqdhan. The story illustrates how a human being, through reason and observation, can arrive at knowledge of God and moral truths without the need for religious texts. This notion of self-discovery through reason underscores a broader rationalist perspective that transcends dogma. The Development of Islamic Natural Rights The contributions of these scholars culminated in the classical natural rights thesis, which posits that rights are inherent to human beings and can be discerned through reason. This idea resonates with contemporary discussions on human rights, highlighting a historical precedent for the recognition of individual dignity and moral agency within Islamic thought. Rationalist jurists such as Ibn ‘Aqīl (d. 581/1185) and Fakhr al-Dīn al-Rāzī (d. 606/1209) further enriched this discourse by engaging with the ethical implications of natural law. They argued that justice is not merely a reflection of divine command but can be understood through rational deliberation. This perspective laid the groundwork for a more nuanced interpretation of Sharia that incorporated ethical reasoning alongside traditional jurisprudence. The School of Illumination, founded by al-Suharwardy (d. 587/1191), introduced a mystical dimension to rationalism, suggesting that intellectual illumination could lead to a deeper understanding of divine truths. This integration of mysticism with rational thought provided a holistic approach to natural law, suggesting that moral truths could be accessed through both reason and spiritual insight. The Decline of Rationalist Influence Despite these significant contributions, the influence of rationalist scholars began to wane after the thirteenth century. A combination of political, social, and intellectual factors contributed to this decline. The rise of more dogmatic interpretations of Islam, particularly in the context of the Sunni-Shi‘i divide, led to a diminishing space for rationalist discourse. The establishment of orthodox schools of thought, which prioritized textual authority over philosophical inquiry, further marginalized the rationalist tradition. During the Ottoman and Safavid periods, while some scholars made noteworthy contributions, their works often remained isolated achievements in an otherwise inhospitable intellectual environment. This is particularly evident in the writings of figures like Mullā Sadrā (d. 1641), who, despite his innovative synthesis of philosophy and theology, struggled to find a broader audience within a predominantly conservative milieu. Reviving the Islamic Natural Law Tradition: The Role of Progressive Scholars In recent decades, a new generation of progressive Muslim scholars has emerged, seeking to revive and expand upon the rationalist tradition of Islamic natural law. Figures such as Ebrahim Moosa, Hassan Hanafi, Muhammad Abed al-Jabiri, and Mohsen Kadivar are at the forefront of this intellectual revival, each contributing unique perspectives that reflect a commitment to reason, ethical inquiry, and social justice. Ebrahim Moosa: Bridging Tradition and Modernity Ebrahim Moosa, a prominent scholar at the University of Notre Dame, emphasizes the importance of reinterpreting Islamic texts through a contemporary lens. He advocates for a contextual understanding of the Quran and Hadith, arguing that the application of Islamic principles must be responsive to modern ethical challenges. Moosa’s work encourages a return to the rationalist principles of natural law, asserting that human dignity and rights are inherent in Islamic teachings. By engaging with both traditional sources and modern philosophical discourse, Moosa seeks to create a framework for Islamic law that is both relevant and just in today’s world. Hassan Hanafi: Philosophy and Social Change Hassan Hanafi, an influential Egyptian philosopher, has been a vocal proponent of a rationalist approach to Islamic thought. His work critiques the rigid interpretations of Islam that have dominated intellectual discourse and advocates for a philosophy of liberation. Hanafi argues that Islamic natural law can provide a basis for social justice, human rights, and democratic governance. By emphasizing the need for a critical engagement with Islamic texts, he seeks to empower Muslim communities to reclaim their intellectual heritage and apply it to contemporary struggles for justice and equality. Muhammad Abed al-Jabiri: Critical Rationalism Muhammad Abed al-Jabiri, a Moroccan philosopher, has made significant contributions to the discourse on Islamic rationalism through his critical examination of Arabic thought. Al-Jabiri’s work focuses on the historical and cultural contexts of Islamic philosophy, advocating for a rationalist approach that moves beyond traditional dogmas. He argues that the revival of natural law theories can help Muslims articulate their rights and responsibilities in a modern context. By reinterpreting classical texts and integrating them with modern philosophical ideas, al-Jabiri aims to foster a more dynamic and critical engagement with Islamic thought. Mohsen Kadivar: The Ethics of Governance Iranian scholar Mohsen Kadivaroffers a contemporary perspective on Islamic ethics and governance, emphasizing the need for rationality in political and legal frameworks. His work critiques the prevailing interpretations of Sharia that often prioritize authoritarianism over justice and equity. Kadivar calls for a return to the ethical foundations of Islamic law, arguing that a rationalist approach to natural law can provide a robust framework for democratic governance and human rights. By advocating for an interpretation of Islam that prioritizes ethics and reason, Kadivar contributes to the ongoing dialogue about the role of Islam in contemporary political life. Khaled Abou El Fadl: The Search for Beauty and Reason Abou El Fadlemphasises the importance of ethical reasoning and the spirit of the law over rigid legalism, advocating for an interpretation of Islam that is both compassionate and context-sensitive. Abou El Fadl critiques the dogmatic tendencies that can arise from a narrow interpretation of Islamic texts, arguing that such rigidity often leads to harmful consequences for individuals and communities. He encourages Muslims to engage with their faith critically and reflectively, emphasising that authenticity in Islam should be grounded in ethical considerations rather than mere adherence to tradition. His scholarship highlights the necessity of understanding Islam as a living tradition that evolves with the times, allowing for diverse interpretations and practices that reflect the complexities of contemporary life. By advocating for a more inclusive and humane approach to Islam, Abou El Fadl challenges the notion that authenticity is merely about following established norms or historical precedents. A Collective Effort Toward Renewal These scholars represent a collective effort to revitalize the rationalist tradition within Islamic thought. By engaging critically with both classical texts and contemporary issues, they are forging a path that honours the intellectual legacy of earlier rationalists while addressing the complexities of modern life. Their work underscores the enduring relevance of natural law theories in articulating a vision of justice that is consistent with Islamic principles. As they explore the intersections of faith, reason, and ethics, these progressive Muslim thinkers are not only contributing to academic discourse but also inspiring a broader movement within Muslim communities. Their emphasis on human rights, social justice, and ethical governance resonates with the aspirations of many Muslims seeking to navigate the challenges of the modern world while remaining grounded in their faith. The Contemporary Relevance of Rationalist Thought In recent years, there has been a resurgence of interest in the rationalist tradition of Islamic thought, with scholars seeking to revive these philosophical insights in the context of contemporary issues. Discussions on human rights, social justice, and ethical governance increasingly draw upon the foundational principles articulated by rationalist jurists. By revisiting their works, progressive Muslim scholarscan advocate for a vision of Islam that embraces reason and ethical inquiry as central to its moral framework. Moreover, the global discourse on natural law has opened new avenues for dialogue between Islamic philosophy and Western thought. The principles articulated by rationalist scholars resonate with contemporary debates on universal human rights, challenging the perception that Islamic thought is inherently opposed to rationalism or individual rights. Conclusion The rationalist scholars of the Islamic tradition laid the intellectual groundwork for a robust understanding of natural law and human rights in the contemporary period as exemplified by progressive Muslim scholars. Their contributions underscore the importance of reason in ethical deliberation and legal jurisprudence, offering a perspective that remains relevant in today's discussions on morality and justice. The challenge now lies in fostering an intellectual environment that allows for the flourishing of reasoned discourse, ensuring that the legacy of these scholars continues to inform and enrich the moral landscape of contemporary Islamic civilization. The efforts of progressive Muslimscholars today further this legacy, demonstrating that the principles of natural law and ethical governance can thrive within the framework of Islam, ultimately contributing to a more just and equitable society. ------ Checkout Dr. Adis Duderija’s personal website at: https://dradisduderija.com/ ---- A decades old patron of New Age Islam, Dr Adis Duderija is a Senior Lecturer in the Study of Islam and Society, School of Humanities, Languages and Social Science; Senior Fellow Centre for Interfaith and Intercultural Dialogue, Griffith University | Nathan | Queensland | Australia. His forthcoming books are ( co-edited)- Shame, Modesty, and Honora in Islam and Interfaith Engagement Beyond the Divide (Springer) URL: https://www.newageislam.com/islamic-ideology/rationalist-muslim-scholars-islamic-natural-law-theories/d/133705 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism