A Possible Scientific Explanation Of Night Journey

By V.A. Mohamad Ashrof, New Age Islam 26 May 2025 Abstract Quran 17:1, detailing the Prophet Muhammad's miraculous Night Journey (Isra) from al-Masjid al-Haram (Mecca) to al-Masjid al-Aqsa (Jerusalem), is traditionally understood as a divine miracle transcending conventional spatio-temporal limitations. This paper embarks on a speculative exploration, examining conceptual parallels between this extraordinary event and postulates from modern theoretical physics, specifically the Alcubierre warp drive, quantum entanglement, and quantum teleportation. While these scientific theories are themselves highly speculative or limited in their current applicability to macroscopic phenomena, they offer frameworks for contemplating the manipulation of space, time, and information in ways that resonate with the miraculous narrative. The Alcubierre drive's mechanism of space-time contraction and expansion offers a compelling analogy to the traditional Islamic concept of "ṭayy al-arḍ" (folding of the earth), potentially accounting for rapid transit. Quantum entanglement’s non-local correlations and quantum teleportation’s state-transfer mechanisms provide metaphorical lenses for understanding instantaneous connections or the transfer of experiential information. This paper reviews the fundamental principles of these theories, their current scientific standing, and their potential, albeit metaphorical, relevance to the Isra. It emphasizes that such an analysis serves not to provide a literal scientific explanation for a divine act, but to foster a dialogue between faith and the frontiers of scientific inquiry, illustrating how concepts once deemed purely mystical may find conceptual echoes in advanced physics. The inherent limitations, speculative nature of the theories, and the theological primacy of divine agency are critically discussed. Faith Meets Frontier Science The Quran contains verses that inspire profound contemplation, often bridging the spiritual with descriptions of the cosmos and extraordinary events. Among these is Quran 17:1: "سُبْحَانَ الَّذِي أَسْرَىٰ بِعَبْدِهِ لَيْلًا مِّنَ الْمَسْجِدِ الْحَرَامِ إِلَى الْمَسْجِدِ الْأَقْصَى الَّذِي بَارَكْنَا حَوْلَهُ لِنُرِيَهُ مِنْ آيَاتِنَا ۚ إِنَّهُ هُوَ السَّمِيعُ الْبَصِيرُ" "Exalted is He who took His Servant by night from al-Masjid al-Haram to al-Masjid al-Aqsa, whose surroundings We have blessed, to show him of Our signs. Indeed, He is the Hearing, the Seeing." (Quran 17:1) This verse refers to the Isra, the Prophet Muhammad's miraculous nocturnal journey from Mecca to Jerusalem, traditionally followed by the Mi'raj, his ascension through the heavens. The event is characterized by its incredible speed, covering a significant terrestrial distance (approximately 1200-1500 km) and potentially cosmic scales within a single night, or even a fraction thereof. While Islamic theology unequivocally attributes this event to the omnipotence of God, transcending known physical laws, contemporary discussions sometimes explore whether emerging concepts in theoretical physics might offer, not explanations, but rather conceptual analogies or frameworks for imagining such phenomena. This paper will delve into three such concepts: The Alcubierre warp drive, a theoretical model for faster-than-light (FTL) travel within general relativity; quantum entanglement, a phenomenon where particles remain interconnected irrespective of distance; and quantum teleportation, a process for transferring quantum information. The objective is not to claim these theories scientifically explain the Isra, an event rooted in faith and divine intervention, but rather to explore how their postulates regarding space-time manipulation and non-local connections might provide modern conceptual parallels to the miraculous journey. We will examine the scientific basis of each theory, its current status, and then thoughtfully consider its analogical relevance to Quran 17:1, acknowledging the profound distinctions between scientific theorization and divine miracles. This exploration aims to bridge metaphorical interpretations with speculative science, respecting the integrity of both religious scripture and the scientific method. The Quranic Account of Al-Isra and its Miraculous Nature The Isra, as described in Quran 17:1 and elaborated upon in Hadith literature (sayings and traditions of Prophet Muhammad), is a pivotal event in Islamic history and theology. Key aspects of the journey emphasize its extraordinary nature: • Divine Agency: The verse begins with "Subhan Allah" (Exalted is He), attributing the entire event to God's power and will. This immediately places the event outside the realm of ordinary human capability or conventional physical processes. • Nocturnal Journey ("Laylan"): The journey occurred "by night," implying a very short duration relative to the immense distances covered, especially if the Mi'raj (ascension to the heavens) is considered as part of the same continuous event. • Specific Locales: The journey is from "al-Masjid al-Haram" (the Sacred Mosque in Mecca) to "al-Masjid al-Aqsa" (the Farthest Mosque, traditionally identified as the Temple Mount in Jerusalem). This defines a significant terrestrial distance. • Purpose – Divine Signs ("Linuriyahu min Ayatum"): The purpose was "to show him of Our signs," indicating a revelatory experience and witnessing of phenomena beyond normal human perception. • The Conveyance (Al-Buraq): Hadith traditions describe Al-Buraq, a celestial steed of extraordinary speed, as the Prophet's conveyance. This further underscores the supernatural mode of transport. Traditional Islamic scholarship interprets the Isra as a physical journey undertaken by the Prophet in body and spirit. The miraculous nature lies in the compression of space and time, enabled by divine power. One concept from Islamic mystical tradition that resonates here is "ṭayy al-arḍ" (طَيّ الأرْض), literally "the folding of the earth," wherein vast distances are traversed almost instantaneously. This idea suggests a manipulation of spatial dimensions or the properties of space itself. The inherent challenge for a purely conventional scientific explanation is the apparent violation of known physical limits, particularly the speed of light as an ultimate cosmic speed limit for objects with mass. This is where theoretical physics, which often explores scenarios beyond current experimental verification, might offer conceptual tools for contemplation. The Alcubierre Warp Drive: Manipulating Space-time In 1994, Mexican theoretical physicist Miguel Alcubierre proposed a speculative but mathematically consistent solution to Einstein's field equations of general relativity that could, in theory, allow for apparent faster-than-light travel (Alcubierre, 1994). Theoretical Basis and Mechanism The Alcubierre "warp drive" does not propose that a spacecraft would locally exceed the speed of light (c), which would violate special relativity. Instead, it suggests manipulating space-time itself. The concept involves: • Space-time Contraction: Space-time in front of the spacecraft is contracted. • Space-time Expansion: Space-time behind the spacecraft is expanded. • Warp Bubble: The spacecraft resides within a "warp bubble" of flat, undisturbed space-time. This bubble is then moved through the distorted space-time region. Essentially, the destination is brought closer by contracting the space ahead, and the origin recedes by expanding the space behind. The occupants of the bubble would experience no inertial forces (no acceleration) as they are effectively stationary within their local patch of flat space-time, while the bubble itself "surfs" on a wave of space-time distortion. The effective speed of the bubble relative to an external observer could be many times the speed of light. Requirements and Challenges The Alcubierre drive, while theoretically plausible under general relativity, faces immense scientific and engineering challenges: • Exotic Matter: The primary requirement is the existence of "exotic matter" – specifically, matter with negative mass-energy density. General relativity allows for such solutions, but no known particles or substances possess this property. Quantum phenomena like the Casimir effect exhibit negative energy densities, but harnessing these on a macroscopic scale is beyond current or foreseeable technology (Ford & Pfenning, 1997). • Energy Demands: Initial calculations suggested astronomical energy requirements, potentially exceeding the mass-energy of the observable universe. Subsequent refinements by physicists like Harold "Sonny" White (White, 2011) proposed modifications to the warp bubble geometry (e.g., a torus shape) that could significantly reduce these energy demands, though they remain colossal. • Causality and Control: There are concerns about causality violations (e.g., tachyonic particles, information sent back in time) and the ability to create, control, and dissipate the warp bubble. The front of the bubble might be causally disconnected from the interior, posing control issues. • Horizon Problem: High-energy particles could accumulate on the leading edge of the bubble, potentially posing a hazard upon arrival when the bubble dissipates (McMonigal, Lewis, & O'Byrne, 2012). The Alcubierre warp drive remains a highly speculative concept within theoretical physics. It is a valid solution to Einstein's equations under specific, exotic conditions. There is no experimental evidence for its feasibility, and the existence of the required exotic matter is unconfirmed. It serves as a theoretical benchmark for exploring the limits of space-time engineering. Analogical Relevance to Quran 17:1 The Alcubierre drive offers a striking conceptual parallel to the "folding of the earth" (ṭayy al-arḍ) described in Islamic tradition and implied by the rapid transit of the Isra: • Compression of Distance: The core mechanism of contracting space in front of the vessel directly mirrors the idea of distance being compressed, allowing near-instantaneous traversal without conventional motion through every intermediate point. • Apparent FTL Travel: The Alcubierre drive allows for effective FTL travel without locally violating the speed of light. This aligns with the miraculous speed of the Isra, bridging Mecca and Jerusalem in an extraordinarily short time. • Divine Intervention as Enabler: If one were to consider divine agency as capable of manipulating fundamental universal constants or creating conditions (like localized negative energy density) beyond human capability, then the "mechanism" of the warp drive becomes a conceivable, albeit divinely orchestrated, process. The immense energy and exotic matter requirements, insurmountable for humans, would be trivial for an omnipotent Creator. Thus, the Alcubierre drive, while scientifically speculative, provides a modern physics framework that conceptually resonates with the Quranic description of a journey where space itself appears to be manipulated to achieve rapid transit. Quantum Entanglement: Non-Local Connections Quantum entanglement is one of the most counter-intuitive and profound phenomena in quantum mechanics, famously described by Albert Einstein as "spukhafte Fernwirkung" or "spooky action at a distance" (Einstein, Podolsky, & Rosen, 1935). Theoretical Basis and Mechanism Entanglement occurs when two or more quantum particles are generated or interact in such a way that their quantum states cannot be described independently, even when separated by vast distances. Their fates are intrinsically linked. • Correlated States: For example, if a pair of entangled particles has a total spin of zero, and one particle is measured to have spin-up, the other particle will instantaneously be found to have spin-down, regardless of the distance between them. • Instantaneous Correlation: This correlation is established faster than light could travel between the particles. • Non-Locality: This property, where the state of one particle is dependent on the state of another distant particle without any apparent local mediator, is a hallmark of quantum mechanics and has been experimentally verified numerous times, most notably through tests of Bell's theorem (Bell, 1964). Limitations: No Faster-Than-Light Communication Crucially, while the correlation is instantaneous, entanglement cannot be used to transmit classical information faster than light. Measuring one particle in an entangled pair provides information about the other, but one cannot control the outcome of the measurement on the first particle to deliberately send a specific message to the second. To understand the correlation, information about the measurement basis chosen for the first particle must still be communicated to the observer of the second particle via a classical channel (limited by the speed of light). This is often summarized by the "no-communication theorem." Scientific Status Quantum entanglement is a well-established and experimentally verified phenomenon. It forms the basis for emerging quantum technologies like quantum computing and quantum cryptography. Its implications for our understanding of reality, causality, and locality are still debated and explored. Analogical Relevance to Quran 17:1 While entanglement does not permit physical transport or FTL information transmission in the classical sense, it demonstrates non-local correlations that challenge classical notions of space and time. Its relevance to Quran 17:1 is more metaphorical and subtle: • Instantaneous "Connection": The instantaneous nature of entangled correlations could be seen as a conceptual analogy for a divinely established, instantaneous connection between the Prophet and distant realities or knowledge. The "showing him of Our signs" could involve an experiential connection that transcends spatial separation, akin to how entangled states are linked. • Transcendent Perception: If the Prophet's consciousness or perceptive faculties were, through divine will, "entangled" with phenomena at al-Masjid al-Aqsa or in the heavens, he could experience them instantaneously, regardless of his physical location in Mecca. This is a highly metaphorical interpretation, likening the interconnectedness of quantum states to a spiritual or experiential interconnectedness. • Beyond Space-time Constraints: Entanglement demonstrates that reality at the quantum level operates beyond simplistic classical intuitions about separation and causality. This philosophically resonates with the miraculous nature of the Isra, which also defies conventional space-time constraints. It is important to reiterate that this is only a metaphorical comparison. Entanglement concerns quantum states of particles, not the transport of macroscopic beings or the transmission of complex information for FTL communication. However, it illustrates that the universe permits forms of connection and correlation that are not bound by classical spatial limitations. Quantum Teleportation: Transferring Quantum Information Quantum teleportation is a process that leverages quantum entanglement to transfer the quantum state of a particle from one location to another, without moving the particle itself. Theoretical Basis and Mechanism The concept was first proposed by Bennett et al. (1993). The process typically involves: 1. Entangled Pair: Two particles (say, B and C) are created in an entangled state. Particle B is sent to the "sender" (Alice) and particle C to the "receiver" (Bob). 2. Particle to be Teleported: Alice has a third particle (A) whose quantum state she wishes to teleport to Bob. 3. Bell State Measurement: Alice performs a joint measurement (a Bell state measurement) on particle A and her half of the entangled pair (particle B). This measurement projects A and B into one of four possible Bell states. This process also alters the state of particle A, typically destroying its original state (due to the no-cloning theorem). 4. Classical Communication: Alice sends the outcome of her measurement (2 bits of classical information) to Bob via a classical communication channel (e.g., a radio signal, limited by the speed of light). 5. State Reconstruction: Based on Alice's classical message, Bob applies a specific unitary transformation (one of four possible operations) to his particle (C). This transforms particle C into an exact replica of the original state of particle A. Limitations • Information, Not Matter: Quantum teleportation transfers the quantum state (information), not the physical particle. Particle C at Bob's location becomes identical in state to what particle A was, but particle A itself does not travel. • No FTL Transfer: The need for classical communication of the measurement outcome means that the overall process cannot transfer information faster than light. • Macroscopic Objects: While demonstrated for photons, atoms, and small ion clusters, teleporting the quantum state of a macroscopic object like a human being is astronomically complex and far beyond current or conceivable technology. It would require measuring and reconstructing the quantum state of every particle in the object, an unimaginably vast amount of information. The "destruction of the original state" also poses philosophical and practical issues for living beings. Scientific Status Quantum teleportation has been experimentally demonstrated for photons, atoms, and even small ensembles of atoms over increasing distances. It is a key primitive in quantum information processing and quantum networking. Analogical Relevance to Quran 17:1 Given its limitations, quantum teleportation's relevance to the physical journey of the Isra is highly constrained. However, it can offer metaphorical insights, particularly if one considers the spiritual or informational aspects of the event, or the subsequent Mi'raj (ascension): • Transfer of "Essence" or Consciousness: Metaphorically, one could imagine the Prophet's "spiritual essence" or state of consciousness being "teleported" or transferred to al-Masjid al-Aqsa or through the heavens. This would be a divine extension of the principle, where the "information" constituting his conscious experience is transferred and "reconstituted." • Mi'raj as State Transitions: The ascension through different heavens during the Mi'raj could be analogized to transitions between different quantum states or planes of existence, with divine power facilitating the "reconstruction" of the Prophet's experiential presence in these higher realms. • "Showing of Signs" through Information Transfer: The divine purpose "to show him of Our signs" could involve a divinely facilitated transfer of revelatory information or experiences, akin to how quantum teleportation transfers quantum information. The analogy is much weaker for the physical journey of the Isra (Mecca to Jerusalem) compared to the Alcubierre drive. If invoked, it would imply a "re-manifestation" rather than continuous travel, with divine power overcoming all the scientific obstacles associated with macroscopic teleportation. Synthesizing Theories and the Quranic Narrative: A Speculative Discussion When attempting to draw analogies between these advanced scientific theories and the miraculous account of Quran 17:1, it is crucial to maintain a clear distinction between speculative scientific modelling and theological understanding. The Quran attributes the Isra to God's omnipotence, a power that inherently transcends human-comprehended physical laws. The scientific theories, in contrast, operate within the framework of those laws, albeit at their most speculative edges. Addressing Physical Transit: The Primacy of Space-time Manipulation Analogy For the physical journey from Mecca to Jerusalem in an exceptionally short time, the Alcubierre warp drive offers the most compelling conceptual parallel. Its mechanism of contracting space ahead and expanding it behind directly resonates with the traditional Islamic concept of "ṭayy al-arḍ" (folding of the earth). • The narrative implies a physical translocation. The Alcubierre model, uniquely among the theories discussed, hypothetically allows for the physical transport of a macroscopic entity (within the warp bubble) across vast distances at apparent superluminal speeds. • The divine agency ("Exalted is He who took...") can be seen as the entity capable of generating the necessary space-time curvature and overcoming the immense physical hurdles (negative energy density, energy requirements) that render such a drive currently impossible for humans. Addressing Experiential and Informational Aspects Quantum entanglement and quantum teleportation, while not suitable for explaining the physical transport of a macroscopic body like the Prophet, offer metaphorical frameworks for the experiential and informational dimensions of the Isra and subsequent Mi'raj: • Entanglement and Non-Local Perception: The "showing of signs" could be metaphorically understood as an instantaneous, non-local perception of divinely revealed realities, analogous to the instantaneous correlation between entangled particles. The Prophet's consciousness might have been divinely "linked" to these signs, irrespective of intervening space. • Teleportation and Transfer of Essence/Experience for Mi'raj: The Mi'raj, the ascension through the heavens, involves traversing cosmic or metaphysical realms. Quantum teleportation, as a concept of transferring a state or "informational pattern" to a new location for reconstruction, could serve as a very loose analogy for the Prophet's essence or experiential consciousness being present in these realms. This is highly speculative and requires imagining a divine form of teleportation far beyond its current scientific definition. Higher Dimensions and Divine Operation Some interpretations of quantum theories, like string theory, propose the existence of extra spatial dimensions beyond the three we perceive. While not directly invoked by the theories discussed, the idea of higher dimensions can offer another layer of conceptual space for miraculous events. The Mi'raj, in particular, could be metaphorically conceived as movement through such higher dimensions, or quantum fields inaccessible to ordinary perception, making travel between distant points in our 3D space or to other "realms" conceptually more pliable. Divine Miracles as Operations Through Higher Laws A key theological point is that divine miracles are not necessarily violations of natural law per se, but rather operations through higher, more fundamental laws of reality known only to the Creator, or direct divine intervention that supersedes or manipulates what we perceive as natural laws. In this context, the mechanisms suggested by Alcubierre or quantum physics could be seen as faint human glimpses into the types of possibilities available to an omnipotent God, who is the ultimate architect of all physical laws. The Quran (55:29) states, "Every day He is in a new manifestation [of power]," suggesting continuous divine creativity and governance. Caveats, Limitations, and the Nature of the Inquiry This exploration is inherently speculative and operates at the intersection of faith, theology, and the frontiers of theoretical science. Several crucial caveats must be maintained: • Speculative Nature of Scientific Theories: The Alcubierre warp drive is purely theoretical, requiring undiscovered exotic matter and facing immense energy challenges. Macroscopic quantum teleportation is science fiction at present. While entanglement is real, its direct application to macroscopic travel or FTL communication is not supported by current understanding. • Theological Primacy: The Quranic account of the Isra is a matter of faith, attributed to divine omnipotence. Scientific analogies do not "explain" the miracle in a reductionist sense nor diminish its divine origin. God is not bound by the physical laws He created but can operate through them, beyond them, or by creating specific conditions for them to manifest in extraordinary ways. • Metaphorical vs. Literal Interpretation: The application of these scientific concepts is primarily metaphorical. They provide a modern language or conceptual framework to imagine aspects of the miraculous event, particularly the transcendence of conventional space and time. They do not imply that God used a literal "Alcubierre drive" or "quantum teleporter" as a human engineer might conceive. • Distinct Domains of Discourse: Science seeks to understand the natural world through empirical observation, experimentation, and mathematical modelling. Religion and theology address questions of ultimate meaning, purpose, the divine, and revelation. While dialogue is possible and can be enriching, conflating these domains can lead to misunderstanding. This paper seeks respectful dialogue, not conflation. • Purpose of Analogy: The purpose of drawing these analogies is not to "prove" the Quran scientifically or to reduce a miracle to a known (or hypothesized) physical process. Rather, it is to show that concepts which challenge our everyday intuition about space, time, and reality—once solely in the realm of the mystical—are now also being explored at the very frontiers of physics. This can open avenues for contemplation and demonstrate that the universe, as conceived by modern science, is far stranger and more malleable than classical physics suggested. Reflections on the Miraculous and the Scientific The Night Journey (Isra) of Prophet Muhammad, as described in Quran 17:1, stands as a profound testament to divine power, an event that transcends the ordinary human experience of space and time. This paper has undertaken a speculative exploration, juxtaposing this miraculous narrative with conceptual frameworks from modern theoretical physics—specifically the Alcubierre warp drive, quantum entanglement, and quantum teleportation. The Alcubierre warp drive, with its theoretical mechanism of space-time contraction and expansion, offers a striking conceptual parallel to the traditional Islamic notion of "ṭayy al-arḍ" (folding of the earth), providing an analogy for the rapid physical transit between Mecca and Jerusalem. Quantum entanglement, while not a mechanism for physical travel, illustrates the possibility of instantaneous, non-local correlations, offering a metaphorical lens through which to consider the "showing of signs" or a divinely established, immediate connection across distance. Quantum teleportation, limited to information transfer and scientifically infeasible for macroscopic objects, might serve as a highly speculative metaphor for the transfer of an experiential or spiritual "essence," particularly in the context of the Mi'raj (ascension). It must be unequivocally stated that these scientific theories, themselves at the frontiers of human understanding and fraught with challenges, do not provide a literal, empirical explanation for the Isra. The event remains a divine miracle, its ultimate mechanism known only to God. However, these theories demonstrate that human scientific inquiry is increasingly encountering concepts—space-time malleability, non-locality, interconnectedness beyond classical intuition—that resonate with aspects of narratives previously considered purely mystical. This exploration serves not to reduce faith to physics, but to highlight how the language of advanced science can sometimes provide new ways to contemplate the boundless possibilities inherent in divine omnipotence. The journey of Quran 17:1, while fundamentally a matter of spiritual and theological significance, invites reflection on the nature of reality, and the scientific concepts discussed, though speculative, expand our imaginative capacity to ponder such extraordinary events. Ultimately, the verse "Exalted is He..." reminds us that the power behind such phenomena is transcendent, and while science seeks to understand the created, faith acknowledges the Creator. References Alcubierre, M. (1994). The warp drive: hyper-fast travel within general relativity. Classical and Quantum Gravity, 11(5), L73-L77. Bell, J. S. (1964). On the Einstein Podolsky Rosen Paradox. Physics Physique Fizika, 1(3), 195-200. Bennett, C. H., Brassard, G., Crepeau, C., Jozsa, R., Peres, A., & Wootters, W. K. (1993). Teleporting an unknown quantum state via dual classical and Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen channels. Physical Review Letters, 70(13), 1895-1899. Einstein, A., Podolsky, B., & Rosen, N. (1935). Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete? Physical Review, 47(10), 777-780. Ford, L. H., & Pfenning, M. J. (1997). The unphysical nature of "warp drive". Classical and Quantum Gravity, 14(7), 1743-1751. McMonigal, B., Lewis, G. F., & O'Byrne, P. (2012). The Alcubierre warp drive: On the matter of matter. Physical Review D, 85(6), 064024. White, H, Warp Field Mechanics 101. Houston: NASA Johnson Space Center, 2011 ----- V.A. Mohamad Ashrof is an independent Indian scholar specializing in Islamic humanism. With a deep commitment to advancing Quranic hermeneutics that prioritize human well-being, peace, and progress, his work aims to foster a just society, encourage critical thinking, and promote inclusive discourse and peaceful coexistence. He is dedicated to creating pathways for meaningful social change and intellectual growth through his scholarship. URL: https://www.newageislam.com/islam-science/scientific-night-journey/d/135672 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism