Beyond Proof: How Religious and Secular Beliefs Shape Our Values

By Naseer Ahmed, New Age Islam 18 February 2025 When discussing beliefs, the conversation often veers, almost reflexively, toward religion and metaphysics. For some, the term “belief” conjures up images of blind religious faith and dogma—a point of contention for those who see themselves as rational, secular thinkers. But to reduce belief to this narrow focus is to miss a fundamental truth: belief, in one form or another, is the bedrock of all values, and these beliefs shape our lives, whether religious, secular, or something else entirely. In reality, belief is much broader than metaphysics alone. Each of us, religious or not, holds a combination of empirical, probabilistic, and ethical beliefs, many of which defy “proof” in the empirical sense. These beliefs may be unprovable in a scientific way but remain essential to our ethical standards, societal norms, and even the laws we uphold. 1. Empirical Beliefs: Beyond Absolute Proof Empirical beliefs are grounded in observable data and statistical likelihoods, yet they are not provable in the absolute sense. For example, consider beliefs like “education improves society” or “democracy fosters freedom.” While backed by data and studies, these beliefs are based on patterns, not certainties. In this sense, secular society also relies on beliefs when navigating choices and outcomes. Such empirical beliefs guide much of our policy-making, healthcare, and social standards, even if they lack the certitude of a mathematical theorem. These beliefs shape our values by guiding us toward what we think is beneficial or desirable based on experience, data, and probability rather than absolute proof. Thus, they remain open to change and adjustment as new information becomes available, and yet they are vital, guiding us in areas where we must act without full certainty. 2. Ethical Beliefs: Foundations of Morality and Justice Many ethical beliefs, like the inherent dignity of each individual, are neither empirically nor scientifically “provable.” Whether religious or secular, the foundation of human rights rests on the belief that each person has intrinsic worth—a concept we can’t test in a lab. Similarly, ideas like equality, justice, and liberty are ethical beliefs that define our collective values and shape laws, but they aren’t conclusions derived from empirical science. Ethical beliefs, therefore, are often unprovable and yet underpin the societal norms that govern us. Their origin can be traced to religious teachings, philosophical reasoning, or simply long-standing cultural values that have withstood the test of time. For instance, the belief that human life is sacred directly translates to the value of protecting life in both legal and moral contexts. For secular people, these values may be derived from humanistic philosophy; for religious people, they derive from divine teachings. However, in either case, ethical beliefs are a guide to our actions and a foundation for justice. 3. Probabilistic Beliefs: Operating on Likelihood, Not Certainty Beliefs based on probability drive decisions and values where the evidence is substantial but not conclusive. Consider the belief that democracy is the “best” system of governance. This is not an absolute truth but a probabilistic belief grounded in historical trends and observed outcomes, not a universally provable fact. Many social systems, from healthcare to education, are designed based on beliefs about what is likely to yield the best outcomes, not what is certain to do so. In a secular world, much of daily life is governed by probabilistic beliefs, even if they are treated as “proven.” Though their outcomes are uncertain, these beliefs guide public policy, national security, and social initiatives. Such beliefs underscore the importance of collective trust and values, demonstrating that belief, in some form, is essential even for the secular mind. 4. Religious Morality Religious doctrines not only establish moral guidelines but also imbue them with a sense of authority and permanence. When moral principles are viewed as divinely inspired, they are perceived as having an objective foundation that transcends human interpretation and cultural variability. This divine authority instils a deep sense of accountability and obligation toward moral conduct. The enduring relevance of these values, many of which have been adopted as secular principles, reinforces the idea that, having been decreed by God, they are optimized for the greatest benefit of humanity. Had they lacked this intrinsic value, they would not have withstood the test of time, surviving through centuries of human experience to become foundational to both religious and secular moral frameworks. 5. Philosophy’s Role in Moral Evolution Philosophy has taken descriptive morality from religion and transformed it into normative ethics, enhancing its appeal to secular minds. The influence of religion on Greek philosophy is also apparent, with terms like "soul" and "good" reflecting theological origins. While religious morality presents these rules as objective truths with divine authority, philosophy repackages them as rational ethical systems. This transformation has made moral principles more accessible to those who reject religious frameworks while still benefiting from the ethical insights derived from them. However, religious morality, being grounded in divine command, retains a greater hold on people and a stronger chance of survival over time. Secular ethics, being open to reinterpretation, can gradually drift away from foundational principles. While reason can reinforce moral values, it can also be used to justify their inversion. 6. The Overlooked Role of Religious and Secular Beliefs in Values Religious beliefs about the sanctity of life, compassion, and justice have provided a durable ethical framework for centuries. Although some may dismiss these beliefs as “blind faith,” they have served as the basis for countless legal and moral systems, ultimately benefiting society. Ethical principles such as the sanctity of life or respect for modesty originated within religious traditions and continue to influence secular laws, demonstrating how religion laid the groundwork for shared societal values. Secular ethics also experiments with new moral frameworks, such as LGBTQ rights. While these rights may seem morally superior against religious disapproval of homosexuality, their long-term impact on fertility and population maintenance remains uncertain. While it is unlikely that homosexuality itself could spread to a majority of the population, shifts in social values that discourage traditional family structures may have demographic consequences. If these trends result in declining birth rates without sustainable alternatives, societies could face long-term challenges in maintaining stable population levels. 7. Why Beliefs Are Essential—Religious or Not Belief, whether religious or secular, provides the necessary foundation for moral values. Without belief, values lose coherence, leaving us with nothing more than arbitrary rules subject to change based on shifting circumstances. A society without foundational beliefs would find it challenging to uphold universal values, as there would be no shared conviction underlying laws and norms. Conclusion: Moving Beyond the “Blind Faith” Misconception Understanding the role of beliefs in our values helps to move beyond the narrow view of belief as “blind faith.” Religious, empirical, or philosophical beliefs are foundational to values. They shape our principles, guide our actions, and define what we deem just and fair. These beliefs support the values by which we live, and the source—whether divine revelation or philosophical reasoning—does not diminish their impact. Rather than dismissing belief as irrational or “blind,” recognizing its universality helps us appreciate the beliefs that uphold the values we all share. … A frequent contributor to NewAgeIslam.com, Naseer Ahmed is an Engineering graduate from IIT Kanpur and is an independent IT consultant after having served in both the Public and Private sector in responsible positions for over three decades. He has spent years studying Quran in-depth and made seminal contributions to its interpretation. URL: https://www.newageislam.com/islam-pluralism/religious-secular-beliefs-shape-values-religion-metaphysics/d/134654 New Age Islam, Islam Online, Islamic Website, African Muslim News, Arab World News, South Asia News, Indian Muslim News, World Muslim News, Women in Islam, Islamic Feminism, Arab Women, Women In Arab, Islamophobia in America, Muslim Women in West, Islam Women and Feminism